Start at 5975 State Route 96 and count up. Eddie O'Brien's Grille & Bar is at 5975. Toritos Cantina is at 5988. Park Place Restaurant is at 6025, and Farmington Hots & Ice Cream sits across the highway from it on Commercial Drive. Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters and New King's Wok share 6081.
Breakfast, coffee, plates, tacos, Chinese takeout and a wing-and-burger bar all fall within about a hundred house numbers. Two more kitchens, an Italian dining room and a pizza shop, stand next door to each other on Route 332. Here is that stretch in order, with what each kitchen is known for and the hours each one posts.
6025 and Commercial Drive: the diner and the plate counter facing each other
The oldest kitchen on the stretch serves breakfast. Park Place Restaurant at 6025 State Route 96 is a family-owned diner serving traditional American food. In 2009 the Canandaigua Daily Messenger reported that it had opened more than 20 years earlier, and that several of its staff had been there for many years. Directory listings show Park Place open daily from 6 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., so it is a breakfast-and-lunch room that closes before most of the strip starts serving dinner.
Across Route 96 is the stretch's newest kitchen. Farmington Hots & Ice Cream opened in spring 2025 in the building on Commercial Drive that used to hold Zoe's Ice Cream Parlor. The Democrat and Chronicle located it by its neighbor, "across Route 96 from the Park Place Restaurant," and described it as a sister location of Henrietta Hots on West Henrietta Road in Monroe County. FingerLakes1.com reported it open later that same day, serving Rochester-style plates.
A plate here is two of something on a pile of sides. The Farmington Hots menu lets you choose two sides from home fries, french fries, macaroni salad and baked beans, with mustard, onions and hot sauce as add-ons. The posted menu prices are $14.99 for a red or white hot plate, $15.99 for the cheeseburger plate, $16.99 for a combo plate and $19.99 for the steak bomber plate. The same menu has homemade soup and a Friday-only fish fry. The ice cream in the name continues what the building held before. Farmington Hots takes orders for pickup and delivery through its website, and it has no seasonal schedule posted there, so call before a cold-weather visit.
5975 and 5988: two dinner kitchens a few doors apart
The evening on this stretch belongs to the other end of the address range. Eddie O'Brien's Grille & Bar has been at 5975 State Route 96 since 2018. Its Farmington page lists hand-packed Angus burgers, wings with 18 signature sauces, specialty sandwiches, tacos, pastas and mac 'n' cheese skillets. Eddie O'Brien's has three locations, and its events team books private rooms at all of them. Its posted hours are 4 to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 4 to 10 p.m. Friday, noon to 10 p.m. Saturday and noon to 8 p.m. Sunday. That makes it the one sit-down dinner on the stretch every night of the week.
Toritos Cantina at 5988 New York Highway 96 is the Mexican kitchen on the stretch. The dishes its site features are the burrito loco, carne asada, carnitas and birria tacos, plus a lime margarita. A legal notice in the Finger Lakes Times dated October 22, 2024 showed Toritos Cantina Mexicana Inc. applying for an on-premises liquor license at this address. Toritos has a different week from its neighbor. It closes Monday and Tuesday, opens 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Wednesday and Thursday and 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and closes at 8 p.m. on Sunday after a noon opening. Toritos also takes online orders through its site.
That leaves Eddie O'Brien's as the only sit-down dinner at this end of Route 96 on Monday and Tuesday nights. Later in the week, the two kitchens a few doors apart give you a choice.
6081: coffee and takeout under one number
At 6081 State Route 96, one street number holds two very different counters. Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters roasts its coffee fresh every day and sells more than 50 varieties by the pound, along with brewed coffee and espresso drinks. Its Visit Finger Lakes listing says the house Canandaigua Blend "is worth the trip." The roaster's locations page lists Farmington hours of 6:30 a.m. to 7 p.m. on weekdays, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. on Saturday and 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. on Sunday. On weekdays it opens just after Park Place and stays open hours after the diner closes.
New King's Wok, a Chinese takeout restaurant, shares the 6081 address. Its directory listing shows 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and noon to 10 p.m. Sunday. Those are the latest posted hours anywhere on the stretch. Those hours come from a directory, not from the restaurant, so a phone call before a late order is wise. Farther east, Byrne Dairy & Deli at 6215 New York 96 is the last stop on this part of the highway.
The Friday fish fry, three ways
Fish fry night shows how close together these kitchens are. Eddie O'Brien's runs a weekly fish fry. Farmington Hots serves its fish fry on Fridays only. The third option is a short drive up the road at Finger Lakes Gaming & Racetrack. The Remedy Bar there lists a Friday Night Fish Fry for $18, with broiled or fried haddock, coleslaw, french fries and tartar sauce. Remedy also serves wings, quesadillas, sandwiches and brick-oven pizza. Elsewhere in the building, the Buffet serves brunch and dinner and the Platinum Grille serves breakfast daily. We wrote about how the racetrack building keeps two calendars running in an earlier post.
So on a Friday in Farmington you can have a bar fish fry, a counter fish fry or a racetrack fish fry, and the bar and the counter sit within a few hundred house numbers of each other on Route 96.
Route 332: Italian and pizza, side by side
Farmington's second dining cluster is two doors on Route 332, and it covers what the Route 96 stretch lacks. Prosecco Italian Restaurant & Jazz Bar at 1550 State Route 332 serves Italian food, has a patio and books live jazz. Its site lists Tuesday through Saturday hours of 4 to 9 p.m., a happy hour from 4 to 6 p.m. Tuesday through Friday, and BYOB on Tuesdays and Thursdays. The jazz nights are covered in our post on the nights Route 332 sounds like a jazz club. Prosecco is also booking fall and holiday parties and catering.
Next door at 1560 Route 332 is Dario's Famous Pizza. The shop has been part of Farmington at least since 2007, when the Daily Messenger wrote about it. Dario's Visit Finger Lakes listing names its local favorites as the chicken tender salad, the Rodeo pizza, the taco pizza and the lasagna pizza, which is topped with mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, sausage and meatballs. The listing shows hours of 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday, and noon to 10 p.m. Sunday. Dario's takes call-in and online orders for pickup and delivery.
Prosecco is closed Sunday and Monday, and Dario's is open every day. On those two nights, then, this pair works the same way as the Route 96 pair: one door stays open.
Before you go
Several of the hours above come from directory listings, not from the restaurants. With Thanksgiving next Thursday, call ahead for Park Place, New King's Wok, Dario's and Farmington Hots in particular. The pattern by address still holds. Breakfast is at 6025, coffee is at 6081, the counter plate is on Commercial Drive, dinner is at 5975 and 5988, and the latest posted takeout is back at 6081.
If you're thinking about a home within an easy drive of this stretch of Route 96, or you'd like to talk through the Farmington market in general, Deanna Nissen Real Estate is happy to help. Get in Touch.